By Ziba Balkhi
When Marina was widowed at 24, her in-laws gave her an ultimatum – marry her husband’s brother or lose her three children and home.
In parts of Afghanistan, it is customary for widows to remarry into their husband’s family – a practice sometimes called widow inheritance.
With women becoming more aware of their rights and gaining financial independence, the centuries-old tribal tradition had been declining.
But women’s rights activists fear there has been a resurgence under Taliban rule.
“Their misogynistic and highly repressive system … has created conditions for the spread of such marriages.” said Tahira Naseri, an Afghan rights activist.
“I believe these practices have increased significantly.”
Since regaining power in 2021, the Taliban have barred women from most employment, leaving widows with few ways to support themselves.
They have also abolished laws and judicial processes aimed at protecting women from forced marriages and banned organisations working to end them.
When Marina’s husband died in a traffic accident four years ago, she barely had time to grieve before the family ordered her to marry his brother.
“They told me: ‘You’re our family’s honour. If you leave, people will say we have no honour.’,” said Marina* who lives in the northern city of Mazar-e-Sharif.
In traditional Afghan culture, a family’s standing in society is closely tied to the perceived honour and reputation of its female members.
Marina felt she had no choice. “What could I have done?” she said. “They would have taken my children away, and I would have been left alone and homeless.”
She would have liked to have built an independent life with her children but could see no way to do that.
Marina now has a baby with her second husband, who is 25 years her senior. But she says the marriage is violent and she is humiliated by community gossip.
“Neighbours and relatives talk behind my back,” she said.
“My husband’s friends tell him, ‘You married your brother’s wife. You must have had your eye on her.’ Then he gets angry and mistreats me.”
WIDOWS SEEN AS FAMILY PROPERTY
Widow inheritance is rooted in the belief that a woman belongs to the family she marries into and in rigid notions of family honour.
But women’s rights experts say the practice is often used as a way to deprive widows of their inheritance and keep assets within the husband’s family.
Refusing a marriage can be dangerous. In 2024, Afghan media reported that a widow was shot dead by her brother-in-law after turning him down.
Widow inheritance is most closely associated with Pashtun tribal traditions, but also happens in other ethnic groups.
However, the practice goes against Sharia law which says consent is a prerequisite for all marriage.
In 2021, the Taliban issued a decree banning the forced marriage of widows.
But women’s rights activists say the decree is meaningless as the Taliban’s hostility towards women has changed social attitudes in ways that serve to encourage the practice.
At the same time, a slew of rules restricting women’s autonomy have made it extremely difficult for widows to live independently, increasing pressure on them to enter into unwanted marriages.
Naseri, who runs a non-profit called Women’s Movement Towards Freedom from exile in Canada, said widow inheritance was mostly expanding in remote areas where patriarchal attitudes remain more deeply entrenched.
INHERITANCE DENIED
On the outskirts of Mazar-e-Sharif, Bibi Ruqia* bakes bread to sell from a courtyard. Her three children are out of school and spend their days collecting cardboard from the streets to fuel the tandoor oven.
Bibi Ruqia, who lost her husband before the Taliban took over, knows just how hard it has become to survive as a widow under their rule.
Her daily earnings rarely top 200 afghanis (£2.30), not enough to cover her living expenses. She and the children mostly survive on dry bread with water or tea.
Bibi Ruqia’s husband died of cancer in 2019. Six months later his family demanded she marry his brother, telling her she represented the family’s “honour” and should have someone to protect her so that people did not talk.
When Bibi Ruqia refused, they withheld her inheritance, threatened to take the children and kicked her out of the family home.
Bibi Ruqia was initially able to support her children by working as a beautician. But she lost her job when the Taliban took over and banned women’s beauty salons.
For a while she sold second-hand clothes on the street with other female vendors, but she says the Taliban harassed them, dousing them with water and beating them with rifle butts.
Baking bread is her last hope, but she is months behind on her rent and fears the landlord could throw her and her children out at any moment.
Under Islamic law, a widow with children is entitled to one-eighth of her deceased husband’s estate.
Before Bibi Ruqia’s husband died, he and his brothers inherited a house, two shops and an orchard from their father. She says her husband’s share is worth approximately 400,000 afghanis.
In desperation, Bibi Ruqia recently approached her husband’s family again to claim her inheritance.
But they repeated that she must marry her brother-in-law and threatened to take her children if she tried to pursue legal action.
Bibi Ruqia has now abandoned efforts to claim her inheritance.
Losing her children is too high a price.
*Interviewees requested pseudonyms for their protection
